It was only supposed to be a movie night. But the Boyfriend and his adult content creator Girlfriend are still reeling from the aftermath of her miscarriage. Their neighbors, an excitable Husband and his apprehensive Wife, are a few weeks into their first pregnancy. The Husband is eager to share the news, while the Wife wants to keep it quiet. When the two couples get together, the wine flows and what was supposed to be a casual movie night spirals into a devastating game of revelations.